- Expand navigation for H-Grams H-Grams
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 001 H-Gram 001
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 002 H-Gram 002
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 003 H-Gram 003
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 004 H-Gram 004
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 005 H-Gram 005
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 006 H-Gram 006
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 007 H-Gram 007
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 008 H-Gram 008
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 009 H-Gram 009
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 010 H-Gram 010
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 011 H-Gram 011
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 012 H-Gram 012
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 013 H-Gram 013
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 014 H-Gram 014
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 015 H-Gram 015
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 016 H-Gram 016
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 017 H-Gram 017
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 018 H-Gram 018
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 019 H-Gram 019
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 020 H-Gram 020
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 021 H-Gram 021
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 022 H-Gram 022
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 023 H-Gram 023
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 024 H-Gram 024
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 025 H-Gram 025
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 026 H-Gram 026
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 027 H-Gram 027
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 028 H-Gram 028
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 029 H-Gram 029
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 030 H-Gram 030
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 031 H-Gram 031
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 032 H-Gram 032
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 033 H-Gram 033
- H-Gram Special Edition: Passing of Supreme Court Justice Stevens
- H-Gram 034
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 035 H-Gram 035
- H-Gram 036
- H-Gram 037
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 038 H-Gram 038
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 039 H-Gram 039
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 040 H-Gram 040
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 041 H-Gram 041
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 042 H-Gram 042
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 043 H-Gram 043
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 044 H-Gram 044
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 045 H-Gram 045
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 046 H-Gram 046
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 047 H-Gram 047
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 048 H-Gram 048
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 049 H-Gram 049
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 050 H-Gram 050
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 051 H-Gram 051
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 052 H-Gram 052
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 053 H-Gram 053
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 054 H-Gram 054
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 055 H-Gram 055
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 056 H-Gram 056
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 057 H-Gram 057
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 058 H-Gram 058
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 059 H-Gram 059
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 060 H-Gram 060
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 061 H-Gram 061
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 062 H-Gram 062
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 063 H-Gram 063
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 064 H-Gram 064
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 066 H-Gram 066
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 067 H-Gram 067
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 068 H-Gram 068
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 069 H-Gram 069
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 070 H-Gram 070
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 071 H-Gram 071
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 072 H-Gram 072
- H-Gram 073
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 074 H-Gram 074
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 075 H-Gram 075
- H-Gram 076
- H-Gram 077
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 078 H-Gram 078
- H-Gram 079
- H-Gram 080
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 081 H-Gram 081
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 082 H-Gram 082
- Expand navigation for H-Gram 083 H-Gram 083
- In Memoriam
- Blogs
- Disasters and Phenomena
- Operations
- Aircraft--Fixed Wing
- Photograph
- Historical Summary
- Cold War
- Korean Conflict 1950-1954
- Navy Leadership
- Image (gif, jpg, tiff)
- NHHC
H-Gram 075: A U.S. Navy vs. Soviets Dogfight, 18 November 1952
29 November 2022
Download a PDF of H-Gram 075 (3.5 MB).
70th Anniversary of the Korean War
U.S. Navy vs. Soviets Overwater Dogfight: Lieutenant E. Royce Williams against Seven Mig-15 Jet Fighters, 18 November 1952
I am way behind on updating the events of the Korean War (and 50th anniversary of the Vietnam War) and more will follow. However, the 70th anniversary of the overwater dogfight between U.S. Navy carrier jet fighters and Soviet air defense force jet fighters over the Sea of Japan on 18 November 1952 is particularly noteworthy. In this action, then-Lieutenant E. Royce Williams engaged in one of the most incredible and unique feats of aerial combat in the entire Cold War and in U.S. Navy history. This action was the only overwater dogfight of the Korean War, and the only dogfight between jets of any U.S. service and Soviet jets flying from bases in the Soviet Union during the Cold War. Flying a F9F-5 Panther straight-wing jet fighter, Williams was outnumbered six to one for most of the engagement by faster, more maneuverable Soviet MiG-15 swept-wing jet fighters (it was two against seven at the very start). There is good reason to believe that Williams was responsible for the loss of at least three and probably four of the Soviet fighters. Williams then brought his badly damaged jet back to an amazing recovery on his carrier. Key details of this engagement remained classified for many years, and there was no conclusive confirmation of the full extent of the Soviet losses until after the fall of the Soviet Union. As a result, Williams was only awarded a Silver Star, although there are ongoing efforts even today to have it upgraded to a Medal of Honor. For more on this engagement, please see attachment H-075-1.
A Short History of U.S. Navy Accidents
I originally prepared the attached paper at the request of Admiral Samuel Paparo (commander of U.S. Pacific Fleet), but I believe it may have wider applicability. In our quest for ever-better safety, it may be useful to understand just how inherently dangerous service in the Navy has been going all the way back to the Revolution—as well as just how extraordinarily good, by historic standards, our record has been since about 1990. Prior to that, accidents on the scale of John S. McCain (DDG-56) and Fitzgerald (DDG-62)—or worse—occurred almost on an annual basis, sometimes even more frequently. This would include 27 Navy ships lost with all hands due to non-combat causes, many of those lost without a trace. It includes at least 23 submarines lost due to accident, most with their entire crews. It includes numerous ordnance accidents, including seven major turret explosions, multiple ammunition ship immolations, and a burst gun that killed the Secretary of State and Secretary of the Navy. In the early days of the 20th century, the Navy averaged about 250 sailors per year killed in shipboard accidents and by disease, and as the number of disease deaths decreased, deaths as a result of aviation, submarine, and on-duty vehicle accidents increased. It wasn't until the 1960s that the frequency of these kinds of deaths began to decrease. It was worse in wartime. In World War I, 431 Navy personnel were killed in combat and over 4,000 in accidents (plus over 5,000 dead of the Spanish Influenza—we did much better during the recent pandemic). In World War II, the service lost 36,950 killed in action and 19,781 to accidents, including 8,184 killed in aviation accidents.
The attached paper contains a reverse chronology of major accidents (or weather-related losses) going back to 1900—it gets pretty mind-numbing in the 1960s and earlier.
My points are the following. One, we should never forget the sacrifices of so many sailors who gave their lives, even in peacetime, to learn lessons the hard way that make the fleet far more safe today. Two, while we should never cease striving to do better, I believe the Navy has cause to extoll our safety record of the last 30 years. Three, if we ever let up on the emphasis on safety, things could be a whole lot worse (and have been, in the past). For more on this, please see attachment H-075-2.
As always, you are welcome and encouraged to disseminate H-grams widely. Previous H-grams can be found here.
Footnotes
- Accessibility/Section 508 |
- Employee Login |
- FOIA |
- NHHC IG |
- Privacy |
- Webmaster |
- Navy.mil |
- Navy Recruiting |
- Careers |
- USA.gov |
- USA Jobs
- No Fear Act |
- Site Map |
- This is an official U.S. Navy web site